Insights & Articles

Medicare needs authority to negotiate drug prices to support its value-based healthcare strategy

 

Despite majority public support for authorizing Medicare to negotiate drug prices, legislators struggle to reverse the non-interference clause that makes it illegal.

 

The non-interference clause

Medicare is legally prohibited from negotiating drug prices directly with manufacturers thanks to the non-interference clause in the 2003 law that created Part D, the prescription drug program for Medicare beneficiaries. The non-interference clause disallows Medicare from negotiating drug prices directly with pharmaceutical manufacturers, interfering in negotiations by Medicare contractors, or publishing any information about negotiated drug rebates.

Instead, the private health insurance plans and prescription drug programs Medicare contracts to implement benefits conduct negotiations for discounts with drug manufacturers. Meanwhile, other government programs — Medicaid and the Veterans Administration—have successfully lowered drug costs by negotiating directly for discounted drug prices and rebates.

Strong public support stands for allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices

According to a KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation) poll published in October 2021, there is broad-based public support for ending the non-interference clause. The poll showed that 83% of the survey participants favored allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices directly with manufacturers. Those in favor included a mix of 71% Republican, 82% of independents, and 95% Democrats.

Proponents of allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices in Parts B and D see Medicare’s ability to negotiate value-based drug pricing as an important part of the overall strategy for driving the U.S. health system towards value-based healthcare and lower drug prices, especially if the outcomes of the negotiations are made known to commercial insurance plans, the Marketplace, and self-insured employers.

Opponents believe that the Medicare system of price negotiations through contracted health plans and prescription drug plans promotes competition among drug manufacturers and protects patient access to drugs. They also cite a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) letter that states giving broad Medicare negotiating authority to the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) would, by itself, “likely have a negligible effect on federal spending”.

Recent legislative actions attempting to eliminate the non-interference clause

In 2019, the U.S. House of Representatives passed bill H.R.3, The Elijah E. Cummings Lower Drug Costs Now Act. Among other proposed fixes, the bill would authorize the Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary to negotiate prices for single-source, brand-name drugs that met certain criteria. When H.R.3 went to the Senate for approval, its progress stalled. In 2021, H.R.3 was reintroduced in Congress.

In November 2021, the the Build Back Better Act (BBBA) passed the U.S. House of Representatives but was also stopped dead in the Senate. Within that bill was an exemption to the non-interference clause to allow Medicare to negotiate prices for expensive drugs covered under Medicare Parts B and D. Despite the defeat of the BBBA, President Biden used his State of the Union address on March 1, 2022 to keep up the pressure and repeated his call to lawmakers to address the problem of drug pricing.

Value-based administrative levers

In 2016 a pilot project for Medicare Part B drugs was created to test the results of allowing Medicare to conduct drug pricing negotiations. It was designed to institute value-based drug pricing using an international pricing index for the few drugs covered under Part B. The prices of some Part B biologics and single-source drugs were tied to their lower average overseas price.

Although the pilot project could have been implemented without congressional approval, several lawsuits and injunctions prevented the implementation of the model. Finally, the Biden administration rescinded the proposed model in August 2021.

Besides the recent unsuccessful legislative efforts for Medicare drug price negotiations, HHS outlined some other possible administrative actions for drug pricing reforms based on President Biden’s September 2021 Executive Order 14036, Promoting Competition in the American Economy. Among the proposals suggested is the use of value-based pricing models:

• To improve transparency about pricing, rebates, and out-of-pocket spending through data collection from health insurers and pharmacy benefit managers

• Implementing Medicare total cost of care models to find ways to reduce spending, affect drug utilization, and improve patient outcomes

The need for drug pricing reforms in Medicare holds bipartisan support, especially as it relates to lowering out-of-pocket expenses for seniors. However, passing the legislation needed to realize those reforms remains a controversial and complicated matter. While work continues to pass drug price reform legislation, value-based payment models can provide data analytics to support drug price reductions in both the public and private sectors.

Lyfegen’s value-based contracting platform

The Lyfegen platform helps organizations join in the healthcare industry’s movement towards value-based care. Our contracting platform organizes the actionable, real-time data needed to implement value-based contracting while relieving the complexity and administrative burden of transitioning out of fee-for-service models.

Contact us for more information about our software solutions and to book a demo.

 

BOOK A DEMO

 

Related blogs

Why Q1 Is Critical for Pharma Rebate Management

READ MORE

Why Q1 Is Critical for Pharma Rebate Management

The first quarter of the year is a pivotal time for the pharmaceutical industry. As budgets are finalized and contracts renegotiated, Q1 sets the stage for how effectively organizations manage rebates, optimize costs, and deliver value.

For those navigating the complexities of pharma rebate management, Q1 offers unique opportunities to streamline workflows, review existing agreements, and ensure every rebate maximizes its potential. This period isn’t just about planning, it’s about implementing smarter processes to stay ahead in an increasingly dynamic healthcare landscape.

Why Rebate Management Deserves Q1 Attention

  1. Reviewing Performance

Q1 is the ideal time to evaluate rebate performance from the previous year. Were the agreements aligned with expectations? Did they deliver the promised value?

By assessing past performance, teams can identify underperforming agreements and opportunities for improvement. This ensures resources are allocated to agreements that drive measurable results.

  1. Optimizing Current Workflows

Rebate workflows are often complex, requiring significant manual effort for tracking, reconciliation, and reporting. In Q1, organizations have the opportunity to implement systems that:

  • Reduce administrative burdens.
  • Automate repetitive tasks.
  • Provide real-time visibility into rebate performance.

Streamlining workflows early in the year creates efficiencies that save time and resources throughout the year.

  1. Negotiating Future Agreements

The first quarter is also critical for renegotiating rebate terms with manufacturers and payers. Updated contracts may include:

  • A move to outcome-based agreements, which tie rebates to specific performance metrics.
  • Adjustments to existing terms based on market changes.

Teams equipped with data from previous agreements are better positioned to negotiate terms that align with strategic goals.

The Role of Technology in Pharma Rebate Management

Technology is transforming how organizations approach pharma rebate management. Tools like those offered by Lyfegen enable teams to:

  • Automate workflows: Reduce manual effort in tracking and reconciliation.
  • Gain transparency: Access clear, real-time insights into rebate agreements.
  • Optimize decisions: Use data-driven analytics to evaluate and renegotiate agreements.

For example, Lyfegen’s platform simplifies rebate tracking and provides actionable insights, ensuring organizations maximize their rebate potential while minimizing inefficiencies.

Start your year smarter!

Q1 is the time to rethink and refine your approach to pharma rebate management. With smarter workflows, clearer insights, and a focus on data-driven strategies, your team can unlock measurable savings and operational excellence.

Book a demo today to discover how Lyfegen’s solutions can simplify your rebate workflows and set you up for success in 2025.

Read More

Rethinking Medicine Payments with Smarter Drug Rebate Management Solutions

READ MORE

Rethinking Medicine Payments with Smarter Drug Rebate Management Solutions

Rising drug costs continue to challenge healthcare systems worldwide. In the UK, the proposed Voluntary Pricing Access Scheme (VPAG) and the NHS’s Accelerated Access Collaborative (AAC) are clear signals of the need for sustainable, transparent approaches to branded medicine pricing. These frameworks aim to control costs through 2028 while ensuring patient access to innovative treatments. Drug rebate management solutions are key to navigating these evolving frameworks. By automating complex workflows, providing real-time insights, and streamlining rebate tracking, these tools reduce administrative burdens, enhance transparency, and unlock significant cost savings.

Key Benefits of Modern Drug Rebate Management Solutions

  1. Automation Simplifies Operations

Traditional rebate management involves resource-heavy processes prone to delays and errors. Modern drug rebate management solutions automate tasks like reconciliation, reporting, and contract tracking, enabling healthcare providers to focus on negotiating better contracts and ensuring compliance with policies like VPAG.

  1. Transparency Reveals Opportunities

Rebate platforms provide granular visibility into contracts, helping organizations identify cost-effective therapies and maximize rebate potential. This transparency aligns with NHS AAC’s goal of improving value and ensuring public funds are spent efficiently.

  1. Real-Time Data Drives Smarter Decisions

Access to live rebate and claims data allows stakeholders to evaluate agreement performance and adjust strategies quickly. With real-time insights, healthcare providers can ensure rebates are optimized, costs are minimized, and patient access is preserved.  

This capability supports NHS AAC’s commitment to accelerating access to innovative medicines while maintaining value for taxpayers.

  1. Faster Auditing Improves Accountability

Delayed reconciliation often creates inefficiencies and compliance risks. Modern drug rebate management solutions provide real-time rebate tracking and payment reconciliation, ensuring accurate auditing and faster resolution of discrepancies. These features are critical for meeting the transparency and accountability goals of initiatives like VPAG.

Why Now?

The VPAG and AAC frameworks prioritize:

  • Optimizing branded medicine spending while maintaining access to innovation.
  • Enhancing transparency for payers, providers, and the public.
  • Redirecting savings to high-impact therapies and improved patient care.

Modern drug rebate management solutions directly address these priorities by simplifying rebate processes, supporting compliance, and enabling healthcare providers to align with evolving regulatory frameworks.

Smarter Practices in Action

Lyfegen is an all-in-one platform designed to streamline rebate workflows, improve transparency, and deliver actionable analytics. By leveraging tools like Lyfegen, healthcare organizations can navigate regulatory changes like VPAG with confidence, ensuring efficient operations and measurable savings.

Looking ahead

As healthcare systems face rising costs and increasing complexity, adopting a modern drug rebate management solution is no longer optional, it’s essential. These tools provide the automation, transparency, and real-time insights needed to comply with frameworks like VPAG while driving cost savings and supporting innovation.

Ready to simplify your rebate workflows? Sign up for a demo today to see how smarter solutions can transform your strategy.

Read More